There are three possibilities which may prevent your cake from rising. Your mix may be too liquidy; remember to measure your ingredients accurately. Or, your pan may be too large. Always follow the recommended pan size for best results. Finally, your oven may be too cool; use an oven thermometer to measure the correct temperature when heating or preheating your oven.
Please log in or sign up to write a review or discussion.
Rating:
pluto (1 discussion) on May 4, 2013 at 12:13 PM
I only have 2 eggs and the mix calls for 3 can I just use the 2
No Rating
donna.l.miller.37 (1 discussion) on Apr 7, 2013 at 02:25 PM
I'm having the "fallen cupcake" syndrom. With all of us having this issue with our cakes, etc.-why hasn't DH responded with a "fix"?
No Rating
C-cake (1 discussion) on Mar 19, 2013 at 01:23 PM
what causes cake to go flat after its taken out from the owen?
Comment by: books4me13 (2 discussions) on Apr 25, 2013 at 02:55 PM
C-cake: usually if it goes flat it wasn't baked long enough. If you are worried about overbaking or burnt edges, drop the temperature and cook longer.
No Rating
mmickunas (1 discussion) on Mar 18, 2013 at 06:58 AM
I've been baking for 50 years and have never had a cake flop. The past couple of months, I have been so disappointed with my cakes. Always use DH - thought it was something I was doing but after reading other discussion items, realize it's not me. Help DH, we love your cakes, but not if they're going to go flat after taking them out of the oven.
Comment by: Flytrap (no discussions) on Apr 11, 2013 at 08:53 PM
Well let me add my DH Red velvet 18oz box to the confusion mix! Something is truly wrong with the mix, I am using my kitchen aid stand mixer chill bowl and attachment, I mix my eggs and oil slowly ( as I've done in the past) slowly added th mix and even the finish product was different in appearance. I poured it in my two floured pans taped out air and placed in preheated (profile) oven! About 30 mins later out they come and only an inch high and sunk!!!! I went to the store and bought Betty Crocker Red Velvet mix in 15oz box repeated same process and BAMM!! The cake rose at least 2inches beautiful... moist ...now a 4 layer cake!! Something is wrong with DH mix ! Maybe it's old, generic ingrendents, wrong expiration date! However Betty to the rescue. I had pics of both cakes but unable to post.
Comment by: xiomara.franceschi (no discussions) on Apr 25, 2013 at 04:08 PM
i do not use DH only Betty C, never have a problem, i always add 1 pudding mix and almond flavor. Never a problem i use one time DH and didn't rise
No Rating
NannyO (1 discussion) on Mar 6, 2013 at 04:17 AM
I thought that it was me. I read some of the reviews and agree we need to do something about it to DH. We support this company and they have left us down. Maybe we should all send them a email.
No Rating
momule (1 discussion) on Jan 13, 2013 at 02:08 PM
I'm so glad I clicked on this website. The only mix I have ever bought has been DH .... all of the rest were just too dry and tasteless. Now, I, too have experience with the cake falling flat. Makes me so mad because it was to be for a special time tonight. It's about an inch thick. I noticed when I put it in the cake pan that it seemed very liquidy but thought maybe it was just my imagination. Wrong! I'll not buy DH again ... this discussion really opened my eyes to the deceit of manufacturers. I would rather pay more and keep what I had. Don't know what to do next ... I do have a Best Choice, maybe I'll throw that one together. Couldn't be worse. Thanks for the comments!
No Rating
randy.smith.5494360 (1 discussion) on Dec 3, 2012 at 02:40 PM
Cakes falling flat..... using new D.H. 16.5oz cake mixes. How can I do to prevent this?
No Rating
beverly.coleman.927 (1 discussion) on Nov 18, 2012 at 07:24 AM
I am VERY disappointed in the smaller mixes. There is a distinct difference in the outcomes I've been used to for years. How can the directions and ingredient amount for the Devil's Food pound cake on the side of the box be the same when there's less mix in the boxes? Unfortunately, all the major brand cake mixes have gone to this smaller package though the price stays the same. Personally, I'd rather pay more for the unaltered, reliable 18.5 oz. mix than have my cake turn out unacceptable. I will not purchase another DH product unless these ghastly changes are undone.
Comment by: kstimson (no discussions) on Nov 27, 2012 at 02:46 PM
Wow! I thought I was going crazy. Have used Duncan Hines for years and get rave reviews from my customers. Lately the white cake falls everytime and I thought it was me. Guess I'm going to have to change also. Can't sell a flat cake and there is no way to make it rise...I've tried several.. Makes since that they decreased the volume...so now all the stuff you add to it doesn't work. Betty Crocker still works fine.
Comment by: rmorrow (no discussions) on Jan 19, 2013 at 09:02 PM
I am totally disappointed in DH.
Comment by: jlgclassof2000 (no discussions) on Feb 20, 2013 at 07:43 PM
just another product to cross off my grocery lists! very sad...I'm starting to wonder if I'm going to starve due to my refusal to pay for horrible food/products!
Rating:
sharon.pollard.351 (1 discussion) on Nov 10, 2012 at 06:06 PM
I have baked over hundred wedding cakes using the Duncan Hines butter cake mix. I always thought that this cake was better than a cake from scratch. I hate the new butter cake mix as it doesn't bake the same or taste the same. I will not use it again. Please go back to the original butter cake mix. I am now looking on line for a good butter cake mix from scratch.
Comment by: ddll36 (no discussions) on Nov 16, 2012 at 10:05 AM
I am in the same boat. I have contacted them and they say they did not change the recipe. I to am going back to baking from scratch.
Comment by: jlgclassof2000 (no discussions) on Feb 20, 2013 at 07:59 PM
I find it astonishing when these companies INSIST that they haven't changed anything. For example, Febreze all of a sudden smells horrible, yet P&G claims nothing changed besides that they added aeration or air bubbles or something to make it stick better to fabric. Ms. Baird's bread used to start molding after 10 days, at most, but now it doesn't mold after I've had it a month, & it also falls to crumbs after just it's just a few days old...funny - it never did that before.
So to all these companies that are boldfaced lying, I'll say "Umm, no, don't insult my intelligence! I know what a product I've been using for 10+ years smells/tastes/feels like, thank you very much." They've got a lot of nerve treating the people who care enough to contact them & provide feedback this way!
So to all these companies that are boldfaced lying, I'll say "Umm, no, don't insult my intelligence! I know what a product I've been using for 10+ years smells/tastes/feels like, thank you very much." They've got a lot of nerve treating the people who care enough to contact them & provide feedback this way!
No Rating
Cakelady356 (1 discussion) on Oct 9, 2012 at 08:09 PM
Okay...I have an issue with the cake mixes being reduced in size. Many people who use these have for many years and have a system and now we have to change that system. Why would you do that Duncan Hines?! Go back to the way they used to be. Quit skimping on the ingredients! I understand a price increase...I can justify that. But to have to change everything about the way I back because you changed the amount of mix in the box is really irritating! Do change an already good thing!
Comment by: hilary.dambach (no discussions) on Nov 4, 2012 at 10:46 PM
I'm so glad I found that other people have the same problem !! I tried
Different temps .... Different butters ..... After 1 cake and 48 cupcakes ...
Today I'm done !!! Either homemade or a different brand !!!!
Different temps .... Different butters ..... After 1 cake and 48 cupcakes ...
Today I'm done !!! Either homemade or a different brand !!!!
Comment by: ddll36 (no discussions) on Nov 16, 2012 at 10:06 AM
They increased the price and lower the quality.
Comment by: ddll36 (no discussions) on Nov 16, 2012 at 10:07 AM
I too have decided to go back to scratch.
Comment by: sherry.spoon.75 (no discussions) on Feb 1, 2013 at 12:16 PM
Logically speaking, ...DH is doing the same thing all other businesses are doing in America. If you look at all products today you see where sugar use to be sold in 5lbs bags now they are 4lbs, dog food cans are being downsized to smaller cans, small eggs are now being sold as medium sized packages and medium sized are being sold as large, Kraft shredded cheese has downsized their quantity. What use to work for a meal for a family of four in a recipe no longer can be used. We have to buy another package of an ingredient just to be able to make what we have been making for years. This is not so much DH skimping as if they are being greedy as it seems you may be implying here. It is a fact of business in America and it"s a fact that has effected our lives. Will this change? Political forcasts shows maybe about the same chance you have in winning the lottery....America might go back to the way it once was.....I wouldn't hold my breath on it. Those days are lost. Accepting will make the transition easier and help us move to a place where we can find solutions to our ever growing problems. My solution is to buy another box and use the amount I need and make cupcakes out of the rest of the batter. It is a sad sad day in America when I sit with my grandsons to explain how life used to be and the freedoms we use to have. I guess that is what keeps the older generation interesting....They have lots of stories to tell....lol I joke here but I do mourn our losses. We have lost a lot.
Comment by: jlgclassof2000 (no discussions) on Feb 20, 2013 at 07:32 PM
Perhaps DH is not being greedy by skimping, rather, they are just not thinking logically (although that can be a major side effect of GREED!) I know in my case, I have no interest in making a DH yellow cake now because I realized that all of the tips & recipes (that I just spent an hour of my valuable time reading) are no longer relevant, as they do not apply to a significantly smaller box of cake mix.
Nor do I want to make a cake using the suggested recipe on the box because I know it's going to be awful if they did, in fact, also decrease the quality. I am sure they did since that is also what every other company in America has done. Many people are oblivious to any decrease in quality, but I've noticed it in a BIG way for almost every single item I buy & find it insulting and pathetic. Maybe I'm a super taster, or just observant to a fault, but whatever the case, I've abandoned MANY of my used-to-be favorite products. Many of them I've given 2nd & 3rd chances, thinking that maybe my taste buds were "off" that day, but after 3 strikes, they're out of my grocery lists!
I don't know how that can be explained by any other way besides GREED OR PLAIN OLD STUPIDITY. They decreased product size and raised prices, and you're telling me that just wasn't good enough to remain profitable & the only way to make a profit was to also start making their products from cheap products that most people have never even heard of? I highly doubt that!
Nor do I want to make a cake using the suggested recipe on the box because I know it's going to be awful if they did, in fact, also decrease the quality. I am sure they did since that is also what every other company in America has done. Many people are oblivious to any decrease in quality, but I've noticed it in a BIG way for almost every single item I buy & find it insulting and pathetic. Maybe I'm a super taster, or just observant to a fault, but whatever the case, I've abandoned MANY of my used-to-be favorite products. Many of them I've given 2nd & 3rd chances, thinking that maybe my taste buds were "off" that day, but after 3 strikes, they're out of my grocery lists!
I don't know how that can be explained by any other way besides GREED OR PLAIN OLD STUPIDITY. They decreased product size and raised prices, and you're telling me that just wasn't good enough to remain profitable & the only way to make a profit was to also start making their products from cheap products that most people have never even heard of? I highly doubt that!
No Rating
josephine.teclacincotta (1 discussion) on Sep 26, 2012 at 05:18 PM
Help! Making a tiered cake. How many cake mixes for each of the following pan sizes. 14x3. 10 x3 and 6x3?
No Rating
carol.ramirez.75286 (1 discussion) on Sep 20, 2012 at 08:57 AM
When using two boxes of DH white cake mix, can they be mixed together or should each box be mixed separately? And if mixed together are the ingredients for each box the same?
No Rating
elizabeth9652 (1 discussion) on Sep 13, 2012 at 07:42 PM
Does anyone know how many French vanilla cake mixes I need for a 14" X14"X2" cake pan?
X X !4 X
X X !4 X
No Rating
Jade 622 (1 discussion) on Jun 2, 2012 at 10:54 AM
My cakes do not rise and are flat. I never used to have this problem could it be because Duncan Hines reduced the amount of mix in the box?
Comment by: mary.ellis.33 (no discussions) on Aug 28, 2012 at 03:16 PM
I think you have something there. I just baked another cake and my cake also fell. I believe it is that they are not putting enough mix in the boxes. This is the second time in less than a week that my cake fell. Its not only having trouble with duncan hines but all the mixes are about the same. It used to be 18.25 in the mixes they have cut it back. I dont believe it is my oven.
Comment by: donco6 (no discussions) on Nov 4, 2012 at 11:55 AM
Just made two batches of butter golden in cupcakes and all the cupcakes rose for the first 12 minutes or so, then fell flat.
No Rating
cfleavitt (1 discussion) on Apr 26, 2012 at 09:35 PM
Why are there no high altitude directions on the new cake mixes? It says to check this website, but the only high altitude directions are the ones for the old mixes.



